Lord Foster asks gambling regulator to look again at Pokémon packs

By: Paul Skidmore
Industry

Lord Foster asks gambling regulator to look again at Pokémon packs, Pexels CC0

Key Takeaways

  • Lord Foster has asked whether Pokémon cards qualify as money’s worth under the Gambling Act 2005.
  • The Gambling Commission says later resale does not by itself make a purchase gambling.
  • The regulator could examine shopping services that add overtly gambling-like features.

Lord Foster has asked the Gambling Commission to explain why Pokémon cards fall outside gambling law when buyers can sell sought-after cards for cash. The question centres on booster packs, where buyers pay a fixed price without knowing which cards they will get.

Sarah Gardner, the regulator’s acting chief executive, said in an August reply that the chance of pulling a card with resale value was insufficient on its own to bring the sale within the Gambling Act 2005. The correspondence was first reported by Kanto Post.

Foster points to a resale market with real prices

Section 6 of the Act defines gaming as playing a game of chance for a prize. That prize can be money or money’s worth. In his 21 July letter, Foster, who chairs Peers for Gambling Reform, asked why cards with a readily identifiable cash value would fall outside that definition of a prize.

Pokémon says a standard booster pack contains ten game cards, including at least one foil card rated rare or higher. Every buyer gets cards they can use in the game. Which cards they get can make a difference to what the pack is worth on the resale market.

He pointed to card shops and online marketplaces where collectors can sell their cards. In October, a collection from a retired decorator in Woking fetched £1.56m at auction, the BBC reported. Foster also asked the Commission to consider the appeal of trading cards to children and young people. In his letter, he acknowledged that many people collect the cards for enjoyment.

“The fact that Pokémon cards may subsequently be traded or sold on a secondary market does not, of itself, mean that their sale constitutes gambling.” - Sarah Gardner, acting chief executive of the Gambling Commission, in her 11 August reply to Lord Foster

Where the regulator draws the line

In her 11 August reply, Gardner said Parliament had not intended to regulate trading cards or football stickers simply because there was an element of chance in the purchase. She said the Commission was carrying out no work on the purchase or trading of collectable cards or stickers.

Gardner said the Commission could examine shopping services that build in overtly gambling-like features. For an online seller offering a chance-based purchase, the question is how that particular service works and whether it meets the legal definition of gambling.

The regulator has previously said digital loot box rewards confined to a video game and unable to be cashed out are unlikely to fall within gambling licensing rules. Foster’s point is that physical cards can readily be sold for cash through ordinary retail channels.

The Gambling Act is back under review

A House of Lords committee recommended in 2020 that ministers use section 6(6) to specify that loot boxes and similar games are games of chance. In 2023, the government backed industry-led protections for video-game loot boxes.

Gardner said changes to the law or the Commission’s remit were for government and Parliament. Separately, the independent Gambling Policy Commission opened a call for evidence in November on how the 2005 Act is working and whether new legislation is needed.

Paul Skidmore is a content writer specializing in online casinos and sports betting, currently writing for Casino.com. With 7+ years of experience in the iGaming industry, I create expert content on real money casinos, bonuses, and game guides. My background also includes writing across travel, business, tech, and sports, giving me a broad perspective that helps explain complex topics in a clear and engaging way.

Add as preferred source Casino.com on Google Your #1 casino news source

Stay updated with the latest in Casinos, Gambling & Gaming

Follow Casino.com for breaking news, features, expert guides, responsible gambling advice, legal updates & financial insights.