Prediction market platforms allow traders to buy and sell contracts tied to the outcome of an event. These can include anything from weather and technology to elections, politics, finance, crypto, and even sports.
With prediction market platforms, instead of wagering against a sportsbook, traders will make and execute trades based on prices that reflect the market’s estimated probability of something happening.
In trading these contracts, if you buy a position and it happens, a fixed amount is paid out, typically $1 per contract. You can also sell before an event ends or happens, potentially leaving a bad trade early, taking some profit, and moving on.
There are two sides of the argument when it comes to prediction markets. Supporters argue that these allow for more accurate event forecasting because they involve thousands of participants, but those against them say that, especially when it comes to sports event contracts, they mimic online sports betting.
The main difference between online sportsbooks and prediction markets' legality is that prediction market platforms are federally regulated and overseen by the Commodity and Futures Trading Commission as Designated Contract Markets. The law that allows all of this to operate is the Commodity Exchange Act. Having the CFTC's stamp of approval allows these companies to list contracts without needing state-by-state approval. The CFTC will review the contracts.
As for traditional sports betting, it’s much different. When the Professional and Amateur Sports Protection Act was overturned in 2018, this allowed for individual states to pass legal sports betting legislation. Each state has a governing body that issues licenses.
Now, the main legal battle is whether something like sports event contracts falls under the federally regulated exchange products or if they’re, more or less, sports betting and should require a sports betting license from each state.
These questions lead to the question of “Are prediction markets legal in the US?” and right now, the answer is that they’re available with plenty of pending lawsuits. When it comes to states banning prediction markets, the only state that has passed legislation is Minnesota.