Pokémon vs Blackjack: University of Calgary Researcher Explores Gambling-Like Behaviors in Card Collecting

ziv chen
By: Ziv Chen
Industry
Card Collecting Gambling

Key Takeaways

  • A University of Calgary researcher is studying gambling-like behavior in card collecting
  • In card breaking, buyers pay for a "slot" and may get no cards in return
  • Influencers can drive repeat purchases, and some also promote gambling products
  • The study is ongoing and qualitative, so it doesn't show how common these behaviors are

Whether it’s baseball cards or Pokémon, every card collector knows that the best part of opening a fresh pack is that rush of adrenaline as you hope to discover something rare. This combination of a hobby you love with the thrill of the unknown is one of the key reasons card collecting has become so popular in recent years.

It’s also why Brady Simpson, a PhD student and researcher at the University of Calgary, began investigating gambling-like behaviors in trading-card collecting. In his research at the university’s Haskayne School of Business, he explores influencer and community marketing at the intersection between hobbies such as card collecting and gambling. 

Simpson’s observations indicate that entertainment like hobbies and card collecting, which aren’t categorized as gambling, still have gambling-like characteristics, such as repeated purchases, chance-based outcomes, and the pursuit of valuable rewards for risk-taking.

I'm currently fascinated by the idea that introducing gambling into different kinds of hobbies, such as collecting cards, coins, or really anything else,” Simpson told casino.com. “This could take away from the experience of the hobby, but on the other hand, if done responsibly, it can add a new dimension to the experience by building new communities.

Brady SimpsonBrady Simpson

The Thrill of the Chase: Pokémon and Rare Collectibles

Simpson’s research is connected to a fundamental fact that is part of the life of every card collector: When you buy a pack of cards, it is sealed, and there’s no way for you to know what’s inside. Every pack of Pokémon or sports trading cards you buy could contain worthless collectibles or that once-in-a-lifetime rare discovery you never forget. Either because it holds sentimental attachment, financial value, or, in many cases, both.

It’s this unknown and the aspect of chance that Simpson says shares characteristics with gambling. He was interviewed in a recent article, where he discusses the recent explosion of Pokémon and other collectible cards alongside the trend of “card breaking”. It is a widespread practice common on platforms like Whatnot, where collectors pay in advance, before the pack is opened, for a ‘slot’, which entitles them to a share of whatever cards are in the pack. The packs are opened, and the cards are revealed by the host (i.e., “breaker”) during a livestream. 

Some box breaks cost thousands of dollars to buy into. Others only pay out if your purchased share is worth above some minimum amount. If your cards are below that minimum, you get nothing. As Simpson points out, collectors who get nothing have literally paid for the chance to win something rather than getting a guaranteed collectible. Unlike when you buy a pack, which leaves you with cards, even if they are of nominal value. 

Major sites like WhatNot have begun to crack down on card breakers who use their platforms to varying degrees. Most would require them to at least send all cards to participants, even if the cards drawn have generated a loss or are of low value. Still, other platforms have no rules about mailing cards. Informal breaking events via Discord or private YouTube livestreams remain unregulated, leaving participants vulnerable to potential scams and possible harm.

While risks and policies vary across platforms and sub-communities, these kinds of card-breaking activities and other trends among hobbyists illustrate the growing connection between collecting and chance. As things move closer to risking a thing of value for the chance to obtain higher value, they get closer to gambling by definition.

Pokemon Collector

Inside the World of Card Breaking

The excitement, the repeat purchases, the risk vs. reward, and the real-time community aspect of card breaking all captured Brady Simpson’s attention as gambling-related behaviors in hobby collecting. 

Having long been interested in the overlap between gambling and other forms of entertainment, Simpson’s study, The Underground World of Influencer Trading Card Gambling or “Breaking,” focuses on this growing trend. The study, which is still ongoing, analyses more than 200 social media posts, 20+ hours of video, and three major online breaking communities.  

Brady Simpson’s research is still in progress, but for now, he has found that breaking is much more than participants paying for a portion of sealed trading-card products that a host opens online in real time; in fact, breaking is much bigger than that. It is an entire ecosystem of influencers, some of whom also promote sportsbooks, casino products, and other forms of gambling, and card collectors who buy into breaks, knowing that they have even less control over the outcome than they would buying entire packs themselves. Many participate with the knowledge that although they invest money to buy a “slot,” they might never see an actual card in return, let alone draw a valuable card worth more than they put in.

The psychology and social element also stood out to Simpson. The social encouragement between collectors in the live chat and the relationship formed between the host and their chat community captured his attention. The excitement these connections cause, like when a host pulls a big card for another chatter, is “often palpable,” says Simpson. 

I like to think of influencers as someone who's a little more distant from the collector than a close friend, but a lot closer than a major celebrity,” Simpson said. “We can see ourselves in these people; they are more like us. When an influencer makes a recommendation, we might trust it more.”

Taken together, Simpson identifies the atmosphere of a card-breaking livestream and the psychology behind it as a new paradigm of entertainment, which is very different than the type of collecting hobbyists engaged in decades ago. However, he notes that not all breaks are the same and that he is currently still gathering data and formulating his conclusions.

What Simpson’s Observations so far Say About Consumer Behavior

While people may disagree about whether card breaking constitutes gambling (legally, it does not), Simpson’s observations point to trends in consumer behavior and psychological questions that need to be researched further. Specifically, the study addresses the broader question of why consumers repeatedly engage in activities with uncertain outcomes. 

Many products today are more than just products. They are lotteries with uncertain rewards that require social media engagement and repeat spending. Another classic example of this trend, which Simpson mentions, is loot boxes in video games, which sell randomized rewards for real money. Sometimes, however, these rewards are entirely virtual and cannot be traded for money. 

When you add in the role of influencers and social media platforms geared towards community engagement and hype cycles, like the TikTok LIVE feature or WhatNot, products become entertainment and a part of the attention economy as well as financial. 

According to Simpson, the role of anticipation and the possibility of an unusually valuable reward is what’s driving this trend. As the chance of getting a big prize becomes more important than the actual item itself, the experience of opening or revealing cards becomes something worth paying for rather than the old days when you knew you were at least guaranteed a collectible (even if it was worthless). 

Anecdotally, I'm seeing many aspects of my daily life being gamified to some extent.” Simpson illustrates. “One good example is the "mystery box" mechanics in toys and video games, which I’m seeing more and more of lately. I'm very intrigued by the idea that introducing gambling-like components into different kinds of hobbies, such as collecting cards, coins, or really anything else.” 

The powerful feeling of anticipation also creates a cycle. Namely, if a person participates in breaks for Pokémon packs and sports-card boxes. They may rationalize additional purchases after losing money on a bad break because there’s always a chance the next one will contain something valuable. 

Spelled out like this, it’s easy to assume that all collectors are actually just gambling. However, it’s worth noting that Simpson's qualitative study only identified themes within certain collecting communities. It did not measure how common these gambling-like behaviors were among all collectors.

Card Breaking Study

The Responsibility of Influencers

A key element that emerged in Simpson’s research was the role influencers play in hobby communities, particularly in the card-breaking space. As a former video game streamer, he knows firsthand how an engaging online personality can build a community with chatters. And he shared his own experience with us. 

I’m not a large-scale streamer. But as I started gaining a following in the thousands, I was approached by gambling advertisers about promotional opportunities. The biggest surprise to me was that the gambling sponsorships typically paid more. In most cases, quite a bit more. I have friends who may not be gamblers or don't necessarily like exposing their audience to gambling content because it's out of their niche or they feel it could impact their audience negatively, but the offer does make you stop and consider where your priorities are.”

In the context of card breaking, a strong influencer can transform trading-card purchases into social entertainment. Influencers build hype with their card reveals and foster a sense of community among traders. Specific things, like public celebration of high-value cards and shoutouts to chatters for good draws, may influence future purchases and introduce parasocial relationships between livestream hosts and regular viewers. 

“I think it can go both ways,” Simpson says about influencers and gamification. “While it builds new communities and adds a new dimension of excitement, it could also have a negative impact on the hobby if not done safely and responsibly. 

Simpson’s research finds that influencers can create a highly persuasive environment in which peer pressure and community-seeking behavior are common. These dynamics are clear when community members are socially celebrated and encouraged to continue to purchase more. Simpson highlights these potentially concerning issues, as younger audiences may be particularly exposed to gambling-like mechanics through familiar collectible brands like Pokémon.  

“Influencers are perceived as more authentic than other spokespeople, especially by a devout audience. When an influencer makes a recommendation, we might trust it more. Therefore, there is a lot of responsibility in having an audience that trusts you and looks up to you,” Simpson says.

Conclusion: Collecting, Chance and the Future of the Hobby

The crossover between collecting and gambling doesn’t mean that you can’t enjoy the feeling of opening a pack of Pokémon cards. The appeal of collecting and the excitement of chance can coexist. 

Simpson's research focuses on the extreme boundaries between ordinary collecting and gambling-like participation. Collecting is not inherently problematic, but as you approach those boundaries through things like randomized purchasing formats, there may be additional risks and behaviors to be aware of. 

In Brady Simpson’s view, collecting cards can remain a hobby centered on physical items that people have enjoyed for generations. But he’s especially interested in areas where collecting intersects with community, chance and gambling-like mechanics. He also believes that influencers can do a lot to create a safe and sustainable environment.     

“I've seen industry leaders actively seek out celebrities or professional athletes who have struggled with gambling to speak to others about gambling harms or spread awareness,” Simpson concludes. “I think influencers occupy an interesting space. If there is a group of people within the collector community that could benefit from hearing about responsible gambling, there is likely an influencer who can speak to that audience.”

Ziv Chen brings over 20 years of experience in the online casino world. A true industry veteran, he helped shape modern iGaming through leadership roles with top operators. Today, he blends that insider knowledge with a passion for journalism, covering the gambling scene with flair. Off the clock, he's a proud Pitt grad and diehard fan of all things Pittsburgh sports.

Add as preferred source Casino.com on Google Your #1 casino news source

Stay updated with the latest in Casinos, Gambling & Gaming

Follow Casino.com for breaking news, features, expert guides, responsible gambling advice, legal updates & financial insights.