Could a Ban on Sports Prediction Markets Endanger Customers?

Michael Savio
By: Michael Savio
Responsible Gambling
Photo by Tim Evanson, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Photo by Tim Evanson, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Key Takeaways

  • Many prediction platforms set their minimum age at 18
  • Sports markets can operate in states without legal gambling
  • Kalshi and Polymarket have ramped up their responsible gambling efforts

The fight over sports prediction markets is finally coming to a close, but one group has been largely forgotten amid the debates.

Many people assume the prediction industry’s sports contracts are luring bettors away from regulated sportsbooks. While this is true in some cases, the industry has thrived by offering sports betting to groups that can’t access regulated markets. This includes players younger than 21 and those who live in states where sports betting remains illegal.

With the future of sports contracts in serious doubt, it's time to start asking what will happen to customers if the industry goes offline in 2027.

Underage Users At Risk

Unlike regulated sportsbooks, many prediction platforms set their minimum age at 18 instead of 21. This has allowed a generation of young bettors to take up the hobby, many of whom don’t fully understand how to do so responsibly.

While opponents of the industry believe a ban on sports prediction markets would protect these young bettors, that seems like an oversimplification. Given how addictive gambling can be, giving it up is far easier said than done.

The biggest fear is that these young bettors will seek out offshore sportsbooks to wager on sports. These platforms aren’t bound by the rules and regulations of the US-regulated market, and have little concern about compulsive gambling. As a result, this would present far more danger than sports prediction markets currently do.

What About Non-Betting States?

While most of the US has some form of legal sports betting available, some states have refused to allow it. However, that hasn’t stopped residents from signing up for sports prediction markets to place wagers. 

This even includes super conservative states like Utah, where Attorney General Derek Brown claims over 32,000 individual Kalshi accounts have been created. While the state continues to warn residents against using these platforms, it hasn’t stopped the industry’s user base from expanding.

Utah is one of the few states that has successfully forced prediction platforms to drop sports markets. That means many new customers can no longer bet on sports, leaving them with no options within the state’s borders. 

Residents can cross into Arizona, Nevada, or Colorado to place wagers, but that’s incredibly inconvenient for customers used to betting on their phones. This may lead some to seek out illegal options, such as offshore sportsbooks or local bookies. 

Is Sports Betting Really Safer?

The sports betting industry has publicly supported responsible gambling, but can it be trusted?

This question came into the public spotlight in September when The New York Times reported that DraftKings uses AI to target struggling bettors. The report claims the operator identifies these users so it can send them bonuses and promotions to keep them wagering, even as they face mounting losses.

Regulated sportsbooks have also been used in several prominent betting schemes, bringing scrutiny to the integrity of US sports leagues. While several have helped identify and convict guilty parties, they have failed to prevent these illegal wagers before the events are completed. 

The sports betting industry has been asked to be more transparent on issues like these, but has largely refused. That has made it impossible to prove these violations are intentional, tying the hands of lawmakers and regulators across the state.

Prediction platforms initially rejected the importance of responsible gambling, but many have changed their stance over the last year. Industry giants Kalshi and Polymarket have led the way and now meet the standards required of sportsbooks. 

While their motivations are easy to question, the result makes it hard to argue that their sports markets bring more risk than regulated sportsbooks.

Michael is an avid sports fan and a veteran bettor from Milwaukee, Wisconsin. He learned the trade from his grandfather in Las Vegas as a kid. As an adult, Michael started picking games for a small sports betting site and has built it into a career. His experience allows him to provide tips and information to help other bettors improve their game. Michael cheers for all Wisconsin pro teams, the Arizona State Sun Devils (his alma mater), and the Ottawa Senators. He specializes in baseball betting but has extensive experience in football, basketball, and hockey. When he isn’t pouring over stats, he’s spending time with his two young children or hiking and enjoying the outdoors.

Add as preferred source Casino.com on Google Your #1 casino news source

Stay updated with the latest in Casinos, Gambling & Gaming

Follow Casino.com for breaking news, features, expert guides, responsible gambling advice, legal updates & financial insights.